Posobiec and Sauer challenged that framing, arguing Democrats had intentionally stripped the emails of critical context.
“Why would you not have released the full chain of emails, Democrats?” Posobiec asked. “Why wouldn’t you give me all the information? You’re selectively making it look like something is edited so that you can’t give me the question he’s responding to.”
According to Democrats on the House Oversight Committee, the emails were obtained from Epstein’s estate and “raise serious questions” about Trump’s past interactions with Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell. In one email from 2011, Epstein wrote to Maxwell that “the dog that hasn’t barked is Trump,” claiming Trump “spent hours at my house” with an unnamed victim — later revealed to be Virginia Giuffre. Giuffre has repeatedly said Trump was not involved in any wrongdoing and “couldn’t have been friendlier” to her in their brief encounters.
Posobiec said that without the full exchange, the meaning is all speculative. “Could he have just been asking about poaching employees?” Sauer agreed. “Very well could have been,” he replied. “That was his MO,” he added, noting that even mainstream outlets had acknowledged Epstein was removed from Trump’s club for inappropriate behavior toward female employees.
Posobiec pointed out that Democrats themselves had confirmed those earlier accounts, saying the new “selective leaks” were designed to build a false connection. “Once again, ultimately, it’s just Epstein trying to pull Trump in and implicate him in his own crimes,” he said.
Posobiec cited Giuffre’s own sworn testimony, where she denied any misconduct by Trump. “She says it’s not true that he flirted with me — Donald Trump never flirted with me. He didn’t partake in any sex with us,” Posobiec read. “She would’ve had every incentive to come forward if something were true. She did not.”
Sauer responded in regards to Giuffre's testimony, “There you go. It’s over. So what else is there?”
Posobiec said, “Trump went to the lawyers running this and said, ‘Please let me know whatever I can do to help you with Jeffrey Epstein.’ He’d already kicked him out of the club,” he said.
Sauer noted that investigators later described Trump as “the most cooperative” of any public figure connected to Epstein.
Both Posobiec and Sauer argued that the release of the partial emails, including one from loose-with-the-facts author Michael Wolff, was meant to generate headlines, not truth. “Epstein clearly wanted to get Trump rolled up in this so he could say, ‘If you’re coming after me, you’ve got to go after him,’” Posobiec said.
Posobiec concluded that the timing of the leak, coming just as the government is on track to be reopened after weeks of shutdown negotiations, was “another coordinated distraction” from the administration’s domestic failures.
“The Democrats know exactly what they’re doing,” Posobiec said. “This is lawfare through leaks — and it’s collapsing under its own lies.”
