Washington, DC
Vol. 41, No. 22a
To: Our Readers
- If election were held to day, Democrats would take over the majority in the House with a 21-seat pickup
- Election analysis in Barron's all wrong
- Prospects improving for Davis in Kentucky
- Republicans likely to hold on to a slim majority in the Senate
- GOP Senate hopes in Maryland and Tennessee looking up
Outlook
- While our seat-by-seat analysis shows Democrats winning the House by a four-seat margin, the overriding question is whether a "wave" will deliver a really big Democratic majority. That presumes an overwhelming sentiment that negates seat-by-seat analyses.
- Actually, waves-overriding all previous expectations-are very rare in recent American political history. The only wave we have seen during the 39-years of this publication was the Watergate election of 1974, when the 49-seat Democratic gain surpassed all forecasts. The gain of 49 was extraordinary because of the very high Democratic level going into the election, raising the party's House margin to an astounding 145 seats. The famous Gingrich election of 1994 was not a wave. We predicted a 45-seat gain, based on seat-by-seat analysis, and the actual pickup was 51.
- The reasons for the 2006 wave talk: a) the huge generic edge by Democrats over Republicans in current party preference, which never has been a good predictor of House elections; b) the mood inside the Washington Beltway, also a poor predictor historically; c) the run of bad news for Republicans and the Bush Administration; and d) unpopularity of President George W. Bush and the Iraq War.
- The Bush-Iraq popularity is a constant and a major factor in many (but not all) races. But the corrosive political fact of higher gasoline prices has been mitigated, and the impact of the Mark Foley scandal has diminished. Still to be determined is how the conservative base's unhappiness over government spending and immigration will factor in the election.
- While Republican politicians are wringing their hands as they await Nov. 7, their Democratic counterparts are euphoric in anticipation of winning back control of the House and perhaps the Senate. However, these are the same Democrats who confidently predicted John Kerry's victory in '04 and their takeover of Congress in '02. A more sober Democratic analyst, who did not predict victories in those two years, currently forecasts a gain of 21 seats in the House and four in the Senate-exactly what we expect.
- Outside the mid-term elections, the big news of the last two weeks was the virtual announcement of his '08 presidential candidacy by Sen. Barack Obama (D-Ill.) on NBC's "Meet the Press." It was no slip of the tongue. Obama clearly intended to show his cards. Although Obama had been on TV interviews all week promoting his book, only Tim Russert asked the right questions. Obama has clearly made the supporters of Sen. Hillary Clinton (D-N.Y.) very uncomfortable, but it remains to be seen whether he has moved too soon.
- Our current count is that, if the elections were held today, Democrats would gain control of the House, with a pickup of 21 seats, but Republicans would kept the Senate while losing four seats.
Barring a sudden reversal of fortunes, Republicans face a major Election Day defeat in two weeks. The results will range from bad to very bad. On Capitol Hill, their outlook is one of resignation and cautious pessimism.
A quick look at the chart off Republican-held seats below shows the potential for heavy losses. With Republicans playing defense across the board, how many of the 20 seats in the "leans GOP" category can they keep from crashing over to the other side? As of today, Democrats +21, Republicans -21.
Republican-Held House Seats In Play |
|||
Likely Republican Retention |
Tossup |
Likely Democratic Takeover |
|
Leans GOP |
Leans Dem |
||
AZ-1 (Renzi) |
CO-4 (Musgrave) |
CT-2 (Simmons) |
AZ-8 (Open [Kolbe]) |
AZ-5 (Hayworth) |
CO-5 (Open [Hefley]) |
CT-4 (Shays) |
CO-7 (Open [Beauprez]) |
CA-11 (Pombo) |
CT-5 (Johnson) |
FL-16 (Open [Foley]) |
IA-1 (Open [Nussle]) |
CA-50 (Bilbray) |
FL-13 (Open [Harris]) |
IN-9 (Sodrel) |
IN-2 (Chocola) |
FL-8 (Keller) |
FL-22 (Shaw) |
NH-2 (Bass) |
IN-8 (Hostettler) |
KY-2 (Lewis) |
IL-6 (Open [Hyde]) |
NV-3 (Porter) |
NC-11 (Taylor) |
TX-23 (Bonilla) |
KY-3 (Northup) |
NY-24 (Open [Boehlert]) |
NM-1 (Wilson) |
|
KY-4 (Davis) |
NY-26 (Reynolds) |
PA-7 (Weldon) |
|
MN-6 (Open [Kennedy]) |
NY-29 (Kuhl) |
PA-10 (Sherwood) |
|
NV-2 (Open [Gibbons]) |
OH-15 (Pryce) |
TX-22 (Open [DeLay]) |
|
NY-20 (Sweeney) |
PA-6 (Gerlach) |
|
|
NY-25 (Walsh) |
|
|
|
OH-1 (Chabot) |
|
|
|
OH-2 (Schmidt) |
|
|
|
OH-18 (Open [Ney]) |
|
|
|
PA-8 (Fitzpatrick) |
|
|
|
VA-2 (Drake) |
|
|
|
WA-8 (Reichert) |
|
|
|
WI-8 (Open [Green]) |
|
|
|
WY-AL (Cubin) |
|
|
Democratic-Held House Seats In Play |
|||
Likely Democratic Retention |
Tossup
|
Likely Republican Takeover |
|
Leans Dem |
Leans GOP |
||
IA-3 (Boswell) |
GA-8 (Marshall) |
|
|
IL-17 (Open [Evans]) |
GA-12 (Barrow) |
|
|
IN-7 (Carson) |
IL-8 (Bean) |
|
|
LA-3 (Melancon) |
|
|
|
OH-6 (Open [Strickland]) |
|
|
|
OH-13 (Open [Brown]) |
|
|
|
OR-5 (Hooley) |
|
|
|
PA-12 (Murtha) |
|
|
|
SC-5 (Spratt) |
|
|
|
TX-17 (Edwards) |
|
|
|
VT-AL (Open [Sanders]) |
|
|
|
WV-1 (Mollohan) |
|
|
|
Either way, it should be almost impossible for him to lose this 66 percent Bush district to Jay Fawcett (D) or anyone else, but he is underperforming right now, leading comfortably only in partisan Republican polls that should be regarded with suspicion. Leaning Republican Retention.
However, Lucas, at age 73, is not the candidate he once was. He seems tired, almost uninterested. As a social conservative, he is unable to use the full DCCC playbook of liberal attacks and pulls his punches against President Bush. Davis is better organized and better financed. He is considered a conservative comer in the House who will be around for a long time if he can get by Lucas. We change this race from Leaning Democratic Takeover to Leaning Republican Retention.
Republicans have ramped up the number of 72-hour campaigners in the district, and they do so at the expense of contested District 2 to the North. The logic here is that if Secretary of State Dean Heller (R) loses the state's most heavily Republican district, that one can be won back in 2008, but a loss of Porter's district would be permanent. The 2nd District race is also much closer than it should be. Leaning Democratic Takeover.
It is unclear whether Bass can be saved in time. He just started a huge phone drive Tuesday to save his seat, and some Republicans remain hopeful that he can bounce back by November 7. Leaning Democratic Takeover.
Rep. John Sweeney (R) in District 20 is sending up warning flags as his race against Kirsten Gillibrand (D) tightens. The public polls vary wildly, but Republicans are now fearful that they have another seriously wounded patient on their hands. Leaning Republican Retention.
The complaint in Washington is that state Sen. Ray Meier (R) in open District 24 won't go negative enough against Oneida County District Attorney Mike Arcuri (D). But Meier's campaign offices have become tense as publicization of Arcuri's personal scandals actually appear to be backfiring against Meier, even though he has avoided bringing them up himself. Meier feels enough pressure that he has convinced the retiring incumbent, Rep. Sherwood Boehlert (R), to come out of hiding and help him. Leaning Democratic Takeover.
The alarming public poll showing Rep. James Walsh (R) losing to challenger and former Rangel staffer Dan Maffei (D) District 25 is not credible, but Walsh leads by only about five points, far less than he is accustomed to at this point in the cycle. This race will be close. Leaning Republican Retention.
NRCC Chairman Tom Reynolds (R) has partially recovered from the initial shock of the Foley scandal. His wealthy District 26 opponent, Jack Davis (D), is an eccentric amateur. But the burden remains on Reynolds to make the comeback and cleanse himself of the Foley situation. The RNC is spending money on his behalf. Leaning Democratic Takeover.
Rep. Randy Kuhl (R) in District 29 has seen his support among women evaporate. Kuhl's dirty laundry - including the old alleged threat against his wife with a shotgun - had been aired before, but now perhaps it is finding a more receptive audience in this tough Republican election year. Eric Massa (D), a former naval aide to Wesley Clark, hopes to take advantage by Election Day. Leaning Democratic Takeover.
Republican-Held Senate Seats In Play |
|||
Likely Republican Retention |
Tossup |
Likely Democratic Takeover |
|
Leans GOP |
Leans Dem |
||
Arizona (Kyl) |
Missouri (Talent) |
Montana (Burns) |
Pennsylvania (Santorum) |
|
Tennessee (Open [Frist]) |
Ohio (DeWine) |
|
|
Virginia (Allen) |
Rhode Island (Chafee) |
|
Democrat-Held Senate Seats In Play |
|||
Likely Democratic Retention |
Tossup |
Likely Republican Takeover |
|
Leans Dem |
Leans GOP
|
||
Michigan (Stabenow) |
Maryland (Open [Sarbanes]) |
|
|
Minnesota (Open [Dayton]) |
New Jersey (Menendez) |
|
|
Nebraska (Nelson) |
Washington (Cantwell) |
|
|
Vermont (Open [Jeffords]) |
|
|
|
West Virginia (Byrd) |
|
|
|
In key municipalities in heavily black Prince George's County, he is registering unexpectedly high levels of support. His volunteers are finding that all of his databases are up to date, signifying that there will be no last-minute collapse on that level, as there was in 2004 for the Bush-Cheney campaigns in Wisconsin and Minnesota. Steele's ads are good, his polls have him within striking distance and he is making no major mistakes, even as his opponent keeps finding new ways to put his own foot in his mouth.
The biggest surprise is that Steele is entering the final two weeks with twice as much cash as the favorite, Rep. Ben Cardin (D). If this weren't liberal Maryland, Steele would be running away with it. As matters stand, he at least has the momentum on his side. Leaning Democratic Retention.
Ford's late behavior signifies that he believes himself to be behind at this point, as the polls narrowly show him to be. The Republican get-out-the-vote operation in Tennessee put even the most optimistic GOP polls to shame in 2004. It won't be a blowout, but this race is Corker's to lose. Leaning Republican Retention.
Sincerely, |
Robert D. Novak |