Kagan: Kelo Destroyed Property Rights In Order to Save Them

Senator Grassley just grilled Kagan on Kelo, the case that suggested that states can simply grab land from A and hand it to B if B generates more tax revenue. Kagan actually said that the goal of Kelo was to "kick it back to the states" -- in other words, Kagan was saying that the Court okayed the Kelo project in order to incentivize states to pass anti-Kelo laws. Well, put me in a dress and call me Shirley if that explanation didn't just explain away the problem with Plessy v. Ferguson. That judgment said that segregation didn't violate the Fourteenth Amendment. By Kagan's logic, this was actually an attempt to incentivize states to avoid segregation laws. This is backward thinking at its finest.

  • by:
  • 03/02/2023
ad-image
Senator Grassley just grilled Kagan on Kelo, the case that suggested that states can simply grab land from A and hand it to B if B generates more tax revenue.  Kagan actually said that the goal of Kelo was to "kick it back to the states" - in other words, Kagan was saying that the Court okayed the Kelo project in order to incentivize states to pass anti-Kelo laws.

Well, put me in a dress and call me Shirley if that explanation didn't just explain away the problem with Plessy v. Ferguson.  That judgment said that segregation didn't violate the Fourteenth Amendment.  By Kagan's logic, this was actually an attempt to incentivize states to avoid segregation laws.

This is backward thinking at its finest.
Image:

Opinion

View All

Kuwaiti fighter jet shot down 3 US F-15s in friendly fire incident: report

The fighter jet from Kuwait had fired three missiles at the US aircraft....

US to begin escorting tankers through Strait of Hormuz 'as soon as possible'

The Strait of Hormuz handles roughly 20 percent of global seaborne oil shipments....

Iran chooses Mojtaba Khamenei, eldest son of late Ayatollah, as next supreme leader of Iran: report

This is despite Mojtaba being reported as one of the 40 top officials killed in Iran during the Satur...

EXCLUSIVE: Trump advisor Alex Bruesewitz saves 7 Americans in narrow escape from Middle East war zone

"I'm grateful to be out, as are some of the other Americans that were able to come with me."...