Allen and Levine were taken into custody on suspicion of harassment and malicious communications after commenting on the recruitment process for a new headteacher at Cowley Hill Primary School in Borehamwood. The messages, which have now been revealed, show the furestrated couple expressing skepticism over the school’s handling of the situation.
In the group chat, Levine sarcastically speculated about the potential consequences of speaking out, writing: "Can you imagine what the 'action' is? Hello, 999, one of the school mums said something mean about me in a school mum WhatsApp group. Please can you arrest them?" 999 being the equivalent of 911 for emergency calls.
Allen added, "No public body has the power to control what people say about it."
Another parent supported them, writing, "This should be a safe group where parents feel free to speak and share opinions about how they feel about the school and its actions and activities, nothing more or less, end of story."
The messages were deemed concern by school officials, leading to police intervention, reports the Daily Mail. After a five-week investigation, Hertfordshire Constabulary dropped all charges, concluding there was no case to answer. However, the incident has sparked backlash, friends of the couple expressed outrage, with one former member of the WhatsApp group saying, "I was utterly shocked when I heard that Maxie and Ros had been arrested – it was a hysterical reaction to the situation and I simply couldn't believe it."
A spokesperson for Cowley Hill Primary School defended their decision to involve police, stating that they sought advice due to a "high volume of direct correspondence and public social media posts" that had become upsetting for staff and parents.
Hertfordshire Constabulary also stood by their response, saying the arrests were necessary to fully investigate allegations of harassment and malicious communications. However, critics argue the case highlights growing concerns about the policing of speech in private digital spaces.
