Connect with us
In style (teleprompter), substance (far Left) and state of the union (9% unemployment), this reelection bid's not Harry-worthy.

archive

Obama’s Resemblance to Truman Is Thin

In style (teleprompter), substance (far Left) and state of the union (9% unemployment), this reelection bid’s not Harry-worthy.

For all of the recent comparisons made between Barack Obama seeking reelection in 2012  to Harry Truman in his stunning upset win of 1948, there are some sharp differences, and pundits should be more careful in saying “Give ’em Hell Harry” can be replicated next year by “Give ‘Em Hell Barry.”
 
That was the conclusion last week of a respected historian who has written three books exploring important presidential years.  David Pietrusza, author of the widely praised books “1960” and “1920” on the presidential elections of those years, was in Washington, D.C., to appear on the weekly C-SPAN documentary, “The Contenders,” about losing presidential candidates who nonetheless influenced U.S. history.  He dropped by HUMAN EVENTS to discuss his latest election-year book “1948,” which brings to life Democrat Truman’s dramatic come-from-behind victory over much-favored Republican Thomas E. Dewey.
 
“Obama’s certainly trying to spin his reelection effort as 1948 redux,” Pietrusza told us, noting the analogies that have been made in HUMAN EVENTS following the President’s fighting Labor Day speech last month to CBS-TV correspondent Bill Plante’s question at Obama’s recent press conference about him following Truman’s lead by running against a “do-nothing Congress.”
 
The historian concluded, however, that Obama will have “certain problems in replicating Truman’s experience.  In 1948, unemployment was under 4%.  The U.S. was recording surpluses—not deficits.  There were no shooting wars.”  All of that stands in sharp contrast to Obama seeking reelection with unemployment at 9%, the deficit at a record high, and U.S. troops in Iraq and Afghanistan.
 
As for Plante’s question about Obama running against a “do-nothing Congress” as Truman did, Pietrusza pointed out that Truman ran against a Congress with Republicans controlling both houses, not just one.  In addition, he noted, “Truman recorded a better share of the Catholic vote than even FDR.  Obama is facing new challenges on that front even as we speak.”  He agreed with HUMAN EVENTS’ conclusion that Obama at his news conference Oct. 6 appeared to be embracing the far Left with his kind words about the Occupy Wall Street demonstrators.  This, he concluded, is far from ’48, when former Vice President Henry Wallace’s far-Left third party challenge freed Truman from GOP charges of radical control of the Democratic Party.  In Pietrusza’s words, “Obama tosses away the opportunity to paint himself in the middle by boasting that he’s a ‘class warrior.’ “
 
“Obama’s style is the complete opposite of Truman’s in many ways—even in how they deliver their message,” the historian told us.  “While Obama remains teleprompter-dependent, Truman could not read properly from the written page to save his life—or job.  It was only when Truman spoke off-the-cuff that he truly became effective.  Truman’s whistle-stop tours brought him face-to-face with millions of ordinary Americans.  Obama’s tours are really structured to bring him face-to-face with donors who will donate millions.”

Newsletter Signup.

Sign up to the Human Events newsletter

Written By

John Gizzi has come to be known as â??the man who knows everyone in Washingtonâ? and, indeed, many of those who hold elected positions and in party leadership roles throughout the United States. With his daily access to the White House as a correspondent, Mr. Gizzi offers readers the inside scoop on whatâ??s going on in the nationâ??s capital. He is the author of a number of popular Human Events features, such as â??Gizzi on Politicsâ? and spotlights of key political races around the country. Gizzi also is the host of â??Gizziâ??s America,â? video interviews that appear on HumanEvents.com. Gizzi got his start at Human Events in 1979 after graduating from Fairfield University in Connecticut and then working for the Travis County (Tex.) Tax Assessor. He has appeared on hundreds of radio and TV shows, including Fox News Channel, C-SPAN, America's Voice,The Jim Bohannon Show, Fox 5, WUSA 9, America's Radio News Network and is also a frequent contributor to the BBC -- and has appeared on France24 TV and German Radio. He is a past president of the Georgetown Kiwanis Club, past member of the St. Matthew's Cathedral's Parish Council, and secretary of the West End Friends of the Library. He is a recipient of the William A. Rusher Award for Journalistic Excellence and was named Journalist of the Year by the Conservative Political Action Conference in 2002. John Gizzi is also a credentialed correspondent at the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund. He has questioned two IMF managing directors, Dominique Strauss-Kahn and Christine LaGarde, and has become friends with international correspondents worldwide. Johnâ??s email is JGizzi@EaglePub.Com

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Advertisement
Advertisement

TRENDING NOW:

Duke Prof: Islam Has ‘Clear Emphasis on the Sanctity and Dignity of Human Life’

FOREIGN AFFAIRS

Willem van Sprouse Antifa Willem van Sprouse Antifa

ICE Detention Center Attacker Was Antifa Activist.

U.S. POLITICS

Beto Is Using His Slave-Owning Ancestry.

U.S. POLITICS

Connect
Newsletter Signup.

Sign up to the Human Events newsletter