Connect with us
Republican state chairmen at the Dallas conference commit to saving states' rights from a popular vote for President, liberals' latest attempt to circumvent the Constitution.

archive

GOP Leaders United in Defense of Electoral College

Republican state chairmen at the Dallas conference commit to saving states’ rights from a popular vote for President, liberals’ latest attempt to circumvent the Constitution.

DALLAS—One political controversy that came up repeatedly during the meeting of Republican state chairmen here May 15 to 17 was the latest effort by liberals nationwide to scrap the Electoral College in favor of popular election of the President.  Almost to a person, GOP party leaders are adamantly opposed to the proposed change and, in fact, several of them told HUMAN EVENTS they hope to put the party on record in its opposition at the next meeting of the Republican National Committee in the spring.
 
The cause of amending the U.S. Constitution to replace the Electoral College and instead adopt election of the President by popular vote is an old one.  Clearly believing that they can turn out voters in their historic bastions in greater numbers than their political opponents, liberals have pushed this change for several generations.  Conservatives, respecting both tradition and the rights of states, have historically supported maintaining the form of electing Presidents crafted by the Founding Fathers. 
 
But what is unique about the latest assault on the Electoral College is that, instead of attempting to abolish it through a constitutional amendment, supporters of the popular vote scheme are instead pursuing what California’s GOP National Committeeman Shawn Steel dubbed “a liberal attempt to end-run the Constitution.”
 
Under this scheme, state legislatures would pass legislation that would bind them to award their electoral votes to the winner of the national popular vote—even if the candidate that got the most votes nationally did not carry that individual state.  In short, this would be a de facto popular vote for President—and done without amending the Constitution. 

So far, seven states and the District of Columbia (with a combined 77 electoral votes) have enacted laws that do precisely this.  Should similar laws be enacted in states with an additional 193 electoral votes, de facto popular election of the President will be achieved. 
 
The California legislature, firmly in Democratic hands, was poised to pass similar legislation this week, but with opponents raising fierce objections, the vote was delayed.  In Delaware, newly elected state GOP Chairman John Sigler told us, “Liberal Democrats in the state legislature have offered HB 55, and all the Republicans are against it.  Republicans here are strongly opposed because it would repeal the Electoral College by implication.  And in basically writing off many states, rural areas, and people, it would lead to rule by tyranny.”
 
“Enactment of this proposal would be disastrous for California and disastrous for the country,” California State GOP Chairman Tom Del Beccaro told HUMAN EVENTS during the Dallas meeting.  Del Beccaro, who has spoken and written vigorously against the change, pointed out that “with Los Angeles County as large as 42 states in terms of population, Democrats would simply have to pour money and workers in there to drive up their popular vote.  When they do the same in New York or Chicago or San Francisco, and this ‘compact’ of the states on electoral votes is law, you could easily have a Democratic ‘lock’ on the presidency.”
 
What Steel, Del Beccaro, Sigler and other Republican foes of this measure find especially upsetting is that several Republicans have bought into this concept.  As Steel told us, “In states like Missouri, Oklahoma and South Dakota, Republican legislators are carrying the NPV [national popular vote] ball.  In the Republican-controlled Minnesota legislature, the Republican-sponsored NPV bill has passed the state house of representatives and recently cleared a key state Senate committee.”
 
Steel blames this seemingly strange GOP backing for a measure backed in large part by Democratic leftists on Tom Golisano, a New York billionaire who is funding the National Popular Vote campaign with his own vast wealth.  Golisano is best known for waging losing bids for governor of the Empire State three times on the ticket of the Independence Party.  His combined expenditures in all three races totaled nearly $100 million. 

“And now Golisano is paying lobbyists and Republican operatives to win over votes in key states,” added Steel.  “I’m not sure he has considered the constitutional question.  Article One, Section 10, bans states from entering into compacts or agreements with other states unless Congress gives its consent.” 
 
Hence, the strong effort at the Dallas meeting among GOP leaders to alert other Republicans to stay away from a growing movement that sharply contradicts what the Founders wanted—and does so by questionable legal means.  As Sigler put it, “The Founding Fathers got it right the first time.”

Written By

John Gizzi has come to be known as â??the man who knows everyone in Washingtonâ?ť and, indeed, many of those who hold elected positions and in party leadership roles throughout the United States. With his daily access to the White House as a correspondent, Mr. Gizzi offers readers the inside scoop on whatâ??s going on in the nationâ??s capital. He is the author of a number of popular Human Events features, such as â??Gizzi on Politicsâ?ť and spotlights of key political races around the country. Gizzi also is the host of â??Gizziâ??s America,â?ť video interviews that appear on HumanEvents.com. Gizzi got his start at Human Events in 1979 after graduating from Fairfield University in Connecticut and then working for the Travis County (Tex.) Tax Assessor. He has appeared on hundreds of radio and TV shows, including Fox News Channel, C-SPAN, America's Voice,The Jim Bohannon Show, Fox 5, WUSA 9, America's Radio News Network and is also a frequent contributor to the BBC -- and has appeared on France24 TV and German Radio. He is a past president of the Georgetown Kiwanis Club, past member of the St. Matthew's Cathedral's Parish Council, and secretary of the West End Friends of the Library. He is a recipient of the William A. Rusher Award for Journalistic Excellence and was named Journalist of the Year by the Conservative Political Action Conference in 2002. John Gizzi is also a credentialed correspondent at the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund. He has questioned two IMF managing directors, Dominique Strauss-Kahn and Christine LaGarde, and has become friends with international correspondents worldwide. Johnâ??s email is JGizzi@EaglePub.Com

80 Comments

80 Comments

  1. Pingback: briefly-discuss-how-these-sources-support-your-main-points – Daixieessay

  2. Pingback: W3 - Essay Mine

  3. Pingback: week 5 Final Paper POL 201 | onlineclassassignments

  4. Pingback: Government discussion 3 | onlineclassassignments

  5. Pingback: NATIONAL GOV. | onlineclassassignments

  6. Pingback: American National Government | Course Scholars

  7. Pingback: Need two discussions completed Asap!!Answers 0Homework Assignment | AquaWritings

  8. Pingback: Need two discussions completed Asap!!Answers 0Homework Assignment | Quickwritings.org

  9. Pingback: discussion Answers 1Homework Assignment | WriteDemy

  10. Pingback: Need two discussions completed Asap!!Answers 0Homework Assignment | Colleden

  11. Pingback: Week 3 Forum 1 POL 201 (New)Answers 1Homework Assignment | Essaydoma

  12. Pingback: DISCUSSION 1 POL201Answers 1Homework Help | Essaypals

  13. Pingback: week 5 Final Paper POL 201Answers 6 1Homework Assignment | Essaydoma

  14. Pingback: Need two discussions completed Asap!!Answers 0Homework Assignment | Essayedi.com

  15. Pingback: DISCUSSION 1 POL201Answers 1Homework Assignment | Agessays

  16. Pingback: The Electoral CollegeAnswers 1Homework Assignment | Agessays

  17. Pingback: Week 3 Forum 1 POL 201 (New)Answers 1Homework Assignment | Essaypals

  18. Pingback: The Electoral CollegeAnswers 1Homework Assignment – essay studess

  19. Pingback: The Electoral CollegeAnswers 1Homework Help | Colleden

  20. Pingback: Week 3 Forum 1 POL 201 (New)Answers 1Homework Assignment | WriteMoh

  21. Pingback: The Electoral CollegeAnswers 1Homework Help – essay studess

  22. Pingback: POL201: American National Government (ACK1704C) Answers 1Homework Help | WriteEdi

  23. Pingback: discussion Answers 1Homework Assignmenmt | Grademain

  24. Pingback: The Electoral CollegeAnswers 1Homework Help - Colleden

  25. Pingback: discussion Answers 1Homework Assignmenmt | Essaydoma

  26. Pingback: Government discussion 3Answers 1Homework Assignment | Essayodi

  27. Pingback: DISCUSSION 1 POL201Answers 1Homework Help | Colleden

  28. Pingback: Government discussion 3Answers 1Homework Help | WriteEdi

  29. Pingback: help with assignmentAnswers 1Homework Assignment | Agessays

  30. Pingback: POL201: American National Government (ACK1704C) Answers 1Homework Assignment | Essayodi

  31. Pingback: help with assignmentAnswers 1Homework Help | Colleden

  32. Pingback: DISCUSSION 1 POL201Answers 1Homework Help | Agessays

  33. Pingback: DISCUSSION 1 POL201Answers 1Homework Help - Colleden

  34. Pingback: Week 3 Forum 1 POL 201 (New)Answers 1Homework Assignment | PM Writings

  35. Pingback: bestconsultant only.Answers 1Homework Assignment | Agessays

  36. Pingback: bestconsultant only.Answers 1Homework Assignment – essay studess

  37. Pingback: The Electoral CollegeAnswers 1Homework Help | Agessays

  38. Pingback: Week 3 Forum 1 POL 201 (New)Answers 1Homework Assignment - Writemia

  39. Pingback: POL201: American National Government (ACK1704C) Answers 1Homework Assignment | Essaydoma

  40. Pingback: Week 3 Forum 1 POL 201 (New)Answers 1Homework Assignment | Essayodi

  41. Pingback: help with assignmentAnswers 1Homework Help - Colleden

  42. Pingback: Government discussion 3Answers 1Homework Assignment | Essaydoma

  43. Pingback: bestconsultant only.Answers 1Homework Help | Colleden

  44. Pingback: The Electoral CollegeAnswers 1Homework Assignment | Colleden

  45. Pingback: help with assignmentAnswers 1Homework Help | Agessays

  46. Pingback: bestconsultant only.Answers 1Homework Help - Colleden

  47. Pingback: week 5 Final Paper POL 201Answers 6 1Homework Assignment | Essayodi

  48. Pingback: bestconsultant only.Answers 1Homework Help | Agessays

  49. Pingback: discussion Answers 1Homework Assignmenmt | WriteEdi

  50. Pingback: discussion Answers 1Homework Assignmenmt | Quickwritings.org

  51. Pingback: discussion Answers 1Homework Assignmenmt | WritePal

  52. Pingback: discussion Answers 1Homework Assignmenmt | Colleden

  53. Pingback: discussion Answers 1Homework Assignmenmt - EssayCabs

  54. Pingback: discussion Answers 1Homework Assignmenmt | Essayedi.com

  55. Pingback: discussion Answers 1Homework Assignmenmt - Writemia

  56. Pingback: discussion Answers 1Homework Assignmenmt | Writedi

  57. Pingback: discussion Answers 1Homework Assignmenmt | PM Writings

  58. Pingback: discussion Answers 1Homework Assignmenmt - BonPapers

  59. Pingback: discussion Answers 1Homework Assignmenmt | WriteMoh

  60. Pingback: discussion Answers 1Homework Assignmenmt | WriteDemy

  61. Pingback: discussion Answers 1Homework Assignmenmt - Colleden

  62. Pingback: Discussion | Course Scholars

  63. Pingback: The Electoral College | Course Scholars

  64. Pingback: NATIONAL GOV.Answers 1Bids 14Other questions 10 | Essayedi.com

  65. Pingback: NATIONAL GOV.Answers 14Homework Assignment | Essayedi.com

  66. Pingback: NATIONAL GOV.Answers 14Homework Assignment | Grademain

  67. Pingback: NATIONAL GOV.Answers 14Homework Assignment | Agessays

  68. Pingback: NATIONAL GOV.Answers 14Homework Assignment | Colleden

  69. Pingback: NATIONAL GOV.Answers 14Homework Assignment | Essaydoma

  70. Pingback: POL201: American National Government (ACK1704C) - Ace My Coursework Blog

  71. Pingback: Government discussion 3 - Wisdomessays

  72. Pingback: DISCUSSION 1 POL201 - Nursing Essays

  73. Pingback: : Prior to beginning work on this discussion question, - Essay Fountain

  74. Pingback: Prepare: Prior to beginning work on this discussion question, read Chapters 5 and 6 in American Government. In addition, read the following articles: “What Are the Arguments Made in Favor – and Against – the Electoral College?,” “GOP Leaders Uni

  75. Pingback: Provide a paragraph that briefly describes one strength and one weakness of one branch of our government: executive, legislative, or judiciary. - Perfect Academic Research

  76. Pingback: Government discussion 3 - Bestpaperhelp.com

  77. Pingback: NATIONAL GOV. : : Essay Fountain - Essay Fountain

  78. Pingback: NATIONAL GOV. : Fountain Essays - Fountain Essays

  79. Pingback: NATIONAL GOV. | My Essay Homework

  80. Pingback: Government discussion 3 - eazyweezyhomeworks

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Advertisement
Advertisement

TRENDING NOW:

Connect