Connect with us
Sen. Sessions dukes it out with Sen. Schumer while defending the Roberts Court.

archive

Sessions Refutes Democrats’ Attack on Roberts Court

Sen. Sessions dukes it out with Sen. Schumer while defending the Roberts Court.

Sen. Jeff Sessions (R.-Ala.) defended the Supreme Court Tuesday against assertions by Democrats that its rulings under Justice John Roberts have amounted to judicial activism.

The Democrats used much of Elena Kagan’s confirmation hearings to attack the current Supreme Court for what they call its activist rulings, particularly the Citizens United vs. Federal Election Commission case, where the court overturned several restraints on campaign spending by corporations.

Democrats—including Senators Dick Durbin (D.-Ill.), Sheldon Whitehouse (D.-R.I.), Benjamin Cardin (D.-Md) and Al Franken (D.-Minn.)—continued the accusations Tuesday in the Senate Judiciary Committee’s final consideration of Kagan’s nomination.

Sessions responded in his closing remarks that the witnesses called during the Kagan hearings “all consistently demolished the argument that those [Citizens United and Ledbetter vs. GoodYear Tire] are activist cases.” He then gave his view of the court, quoting the famous analogy given by Justice Roberts himself.

“One is the judge as a neutral umpire,” said Sen. Sessions, at which point Sen. Charles Schumer (D-NY) chuckled. “That’s what I was taught. We were taught all along. I see Sen. Schumer smiles and laughs, he thinks this is ridiculous to discuss that a judge could be a neutral…”

“It’s just, whose definition of neutral?” Schumer interjected. “Many of us think Citizens United was not definition of a neutral umpire. That’s all.”

“Well, we had witnesses that testified for the nominee who believed that was not an activist decision,” Sessions responded (watch the exchange at the 1 minute mark in the video below).

Sessions went on to defend the Supreme Court’s decision in Citizens United and closed by warning against judicial activism.

Newsletter Signup.

Sign up to the Human Events newsletter

Written By

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Advertisement
Advertisement

TRENDING NOW:

Dunkin Donuts Refuses to Get Woke: ‘We Are Not Starbucks’

CULTURE

‘Reaganesque’: Economist Tells CNBC Trump Could Shift Global Order In China Trade War

FOREIGN AFFAIRS

Does ‘Impeach Trump’ Amash Have Financial Interests in China?

FOREIGN AFFAIRS

Judge Who Ruled on Trump’s Finances is an Obama Donor.

U.S. POLITICS

Connect
Newsletter Signup.

Sign up to the Human Events newsletter